BUY on AMAZON.COM   "Ian Williams’s wittily written work on 'The Alms Trade' is a tour de force of history, sociology, social policy and the law in action.... A great read!" Professor Roger Clark, Rutgers University Law School.

IAN WILLIAMS' LATEST BOOK: THE ALMS TRADE: REVIEW BY PROFESSOR ROGER CLARK: 28/02/2008 (MaximsNews Network) 

UNITED NATIONS - / MaximsNews Network / - 28 February 2008 -- Ian Williams’s wittily written work on the “Alms Trade” is a tour de force of history, sociology, social policy and the law in action. 

It examines a myriad of issues in the English history of charitable works from around “time immemorial” (the reign of Richard the Lionheart or thereabouts) until the reign of Margaret Thatcher. 

In the course of this delightful romp he addresses cosmic questions like “what is a charity”? One might reasonably ask “who cares?” 

The answer is that all sorts of functional matters hinge on the answer – like the validity of testamentary dispositions and tax liability (the immunity from such liability being a great generator of contributions).

What to class as a charity still turns in English law (and in many parts of the Commonwealth and the United States) on what to make of the preamble to the 1601 Statute of Charitable Uses, adopted towards the end of the reign of Elizabeth the First to rationalize the area. 

Its language was largely plagiarized from William Langland’s Piers the Plowman written in the late 1300s – not the last time the law messed up great literature. Applying it to the testamentary wishes of ordinary people (if such there be) leads inexorably to disaster and incoherence.

Among the many legal disasters that Williams discusses is Chichester Diocesan Fund v. Simpson a 1944 decision of the House of Lords that caused me nightmares as a law student nearly five decades ago. 

Caleb Diplock left a sizeable estate to “such charitable institution or institutions or charitable or other benevolent objects in England” as his trustees should select.

That ugly little “or” in there doomed the bequest to be “void for uncertainty”. “Charitable” was something that any competent trustee or judge could work out, but “benevolent” was too much for an Englishman to fathom. 

(One of their Lordships found it “disconcerting” that the disposition might have been perfectly intelligible in Scotland – as it had been to the trustees until the gold-diggers and the litigators got to work.) 

Distant heirs were able to get the money back from the trustees (one of whom committed suicide) and from the 139 charitable beneficiaries who had been cheerfully spending it on good works. 

The latter, having received it under a “mistake of law” had to disgorge. (The lawyer’s moral of that one is to be well-insured against malpractice!) There are lots of other sad stories like that one in here.
A great read!

Roger Clark, Board of Governors Professor, Rutgers Law School, Camden, New Jersey

Labels: Ian Williams, Roger Clark, Alms Trade Book Review,

~~~~~ MaximsNews.com, An Independent Voice from the U.N., provides commentary and analysis from leading world figures: King Abdullah II (Jordan), HRH Prince Zeid Ra'ad Zeid Al-Hussein (Jordan), Sir Brian Urquhart, Hans Blix, Amb. Richard Holbrooke, Anwar Ibrahim, Bianca Jagger, Dr. Nafis Sadik, Shashi Tharoor, Thoraya Ahmed Obaid, Noeleen Heyzer, Masood Haider, Kerry Kennedy, Ian Williams, Stephen Schlesinger, Sen. Timothy E. Wirth, Marc Morial, Amb. Jayantha Dhanapala (Sri Lanka), Amb. Pierre Schori (Sweden), Amb. William H. Luers, Susan Roosevelt Weld, Rory Kennedy, Mehri Madarshahi, Hazel Henderson, Donald Wheeler, J. Michael Adams, Gloria Feldt, Jeffrey Laurenti,  Ashley Bommer, Rory O'Connor, Genevieve Stamper, Max Stamper and others.

REACH THE WORLD'S MOST INFLUENTIAL PEOPLE   FOR BANNER ADS, contact:  ElsieHillman@MaximsNews.com TO SUBMIT YOUR PRESS RELEASES, contact: TomHerkins@MaximsNews.com   Advertisement

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

MaximsNews® LLC  
NEWS NETWORK FOR THE INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY 

MaximsNews Network® LLC is a Global News Network reaching over 30,000 in the International Community. It is associated with MediaChannel.org and Globalvision News Network, global news and media information services with more than 350 news affiliates in 135 countries. Established in 1999.  

The views expressed are the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of MaximsNews® LLC.

MaximsNews.com U.N. ® LLC  www.MaximsNews.com | MaximsNews@MaximsNews.com | Please contact us about Republishing: Syndication@MaximsNews.com ©Copyrights 1999 - 2008, MaximsNews® LLC. All rights reserved.