|
URGENT:
Please Sign up for your FREE SUBSCRIPTION NOW.
On Right Column.*
Why
The USA
Didn’t have a 1945 Moment
The
MaximsNews Global Pundit
by
Ian Williams
The
MaximsNews Global Pundit is also a
journalist, U.N. Correspondent for The Nation
and the past president of the United Nations
Correspondents Association.
IanWilliams@MaximsNews.com
UNITED NATIONS - 15 July 2005 / www.MaximsNews.com
/ Why
didn’t 1945 happen in the
USA
?
Of
course it did, in the sense of celebration of VJ
and VE days and the return of the millions of
troops to civilian life with renewed
expectations, but there was no VL day in the
US
, no triumph of Labour as happened in
Britain
.
We
now take it for granted that the United States
is a socialist- free zone, but it was not always
so.
At
its peak in 1912, the indigenous Socialist party
had 118,000 members spread across the
country.
It
claimed 323 English and foreign-language
publications with a total circulation probably
in excess of two million, one of which alone,
out of
Kansas
, now the most conservative of States, had
761,747 copies sold weekly.
That
same year Eugene V. Debs polled 6 percent of the
Presidential vote and Socialists were mayors in
79 cities.
Then,
in the wake of the Russian revolution,
sectarianism based on inappropriate foreign
models infected the socialist movement.
The
Communists split from it and then successive
waves of Trotskyists infiltrated what was left
and then quit leaving it shattered, while
between them all the various Leninist factions
replaced egalitarian and populist American
socialism with a Leninist transplant.
The
final death blow to socialism as an effective
political influence in the
USA
was communist-inspired attempt to run Henry
Wallace against Truman in 1948, which led much
of the American Left into the wilderness from
which they have never really emerged.
They
would much rather argue about US policy towards
Kosovo or
Korea
than cope with the absence of a national health
care system.
Indeed
much of the avowed American left, in its
ideological purity, was pretty much cheering for
a Labour defeat in Britain this May, and many of
them now scorn Bernie Sanders, the one member of
Congress actually elected as a socialist,
because of what they see as his compromises.
That,
of course, comes to the nub of the
issue.
As
an elected representative, Sanders, who is now
running for the Senate, has to deal with
reality, and be accountable for his
actions.
Only
unelected ideologues have the luxury of ignoring
reality in their formulations.
The
core difference between the fate of the American
Socialist Party and the British Labour Party is
the union connection.
The
unions and their members, the cooperative
societies, and other such organizations
preserved the Labour Party from Leninist
irrelevancy and ensured that it had to deal with
real issues of real concern to the mass of
working people, whose support it could keep.
The
ILP, and its leader James Maxton, (according to
Gordon Brown’s reverential biography) had
pioneered the original “
Third Way
,” and the “
British Road
to Socialism,” both concepts usurped and
distorted by others, as a democratic socialist
solution to the over-riding problems of poverty
and inequality.
George
Orwell, former ILP member and self-proclaimed
Labour supporter, pointed out that even in
Britain
ideologists misjudged working people, who wanted
jam tomorrow, not planned pie in some Soviet sky
in the far distant future.
For
most working people, “Socialism means, or at
least is associated with, higher wages, shorter
hours, better houses, all-round social
insurance,” he wrote in 1947, advocating a
united socialist
Europe
.
He
anticipated that the loss of empire would reduce
working class living standards.
In
fact, it didn’t, and the 1945 Labour
Government in that sense exceeded
expectations.
It
saw the beginning of new and unprecedented
prosperity and security for most British people.
Certainly
anyone who compared the results achieved by
British Labour and West European
social-democracy and with those achieved by
their more millenarian comrades in the former
Communist countries or indeed in the
United States
could hardly impugn the wisdom of European
workers’ choice.
Despite
Thatcherite and indeed Blairite erosion, the
basic 1945 principles of health care, housing,
social security and free education have
contrived to make Britain, the monarchy and the
House of Lords notwithstanding, a more open
society than the US, which has yet to provide
paid maternity leave for women workers, and
where most workers get two weeks holiday a year
– if they dare take it.
In
the
US
, adult life-spans are now lower and infant
mortality is higher than in most of
Europe
.
Intriguingly,
recent statistics show that Europeans are on
average taller than Americans, reflecting better
nutrition and health care.
And
actual employees in the
US
have been on an effective salary freeze for
thirty years in the face of hugely growing
productivity and corporate profits.
There
was indeed a fork on the road in 1945, and
Britain
and much of
Europe
took the better route, eschewing both American
neo-liberal and Soviet Leninist directions.
Despite
the attempts to divert us onto other tracks, any
comparison with the US, or the tattered remnants
of the Soviet Union shows that this original
Third Way is the road with the best prospects
– as long as we keep moving forward and do not
go into reverse.
And
for all its problems, the Labour Party is still
the best vehicle for the trip, if we can keep it
out the hands of the sects - both left and
right.
The
American lesson is that the union
connection is essential to keep the show on the
road.
IanWilliams@MaximsNews.com
|
Paid
Advertisement: Ads@MaximsNews.com
Rum:
A Social and Sociable History of the Real
Spirit of 1776,
by
Ian Williams
Pre-Order
your advance copy NOW from Amazon.com.
Published
by Nation
Books.

Ian
Williams
discusses the more sociable aspects of rum
with Tom Roper former Australian cabinet
minister, and Trinidad and Tobago's
current Minister of Tourism, Howard Chin
Lee.
"Triumphantly
restores rum’s rightful place in
history..."
"Rum
was to the eighteenth century what oil is
to the present."
"Rum
was one of the major engines of the
American Revolution... a fact often
missing from histories of "the
era."
"RUM
shows that even the Puritans took a shot
now and then."
"RUM
explains the showdown between the Bacardi
family and Fidel Castro..."
|
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
URGENT:
Please Sign up for your FREE SUBSCRIPTION NOW.
On Right Column.*
MaximsNews Network® LLC Reaching Over 10,000 in the International Community, is associated with MediaChannel.org and Globalvision News Network, global news and media information services with more than
350 news affiliates in 135 countries.
MaximsNews®LLC is in partnership with the United Nations Foundation and the Better World Fund.
MaximsNews Institute is in partnership with the World Policy Institute, New School University.
Diplomats, donors, key United Nations Officials, U.N. activists, all Missions to the U.N., all NGOs, journalists, activists in human rights, women's rights, African-American rights, peace, the environment, development and poverty, public policy experts, political figures, and academics.
Syndicated globally by RSS and XML feeds, GOOGLE NEWS, broadcast email, Blogs, streaming video, Internet and news wire services. For Free Subscription, RSS, or XML feeds to your website, contact: MaximsNews@MaximsNews.com
Max Stamper, Ph.D., London School of Economics, Publisher, DrMaxStamper@MaximsNews.com
Genevieve Stamper, Vassar, Associate Publisher, GenevieveStamper@MaximsNews.com
Front
Page |
About Max Stamper | Key Clients | International Affairs | Media Tools | The History of MaximsNews
Max Stamper is eager to explore your international public affairs and communication needs, and to discuss our services. Phone: +1.201.848.6162
Suite 112, 76 North Maple Ave., Ridgewood, NJ 07450 U.S.A.
MaximsNews Network® LLC
The views expressed are the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of MaximsNews® LLC
www.MaximsNews.com MaximsNews@MaximsNews.com
© Copyrights 1999 - 2005, MaximsNews® LLC. All rights reserved.
URGENT:
Please Sign up for your FREE SUBSCRIPTION NOW.
On Right Column.*
To
Unsubscribe: Unsubscribe@MaximsNews.com
|